In order for behavioural altruism or the capability of acquiring altruistic behaviours culturally to survive in a population in the long term it must be, at the least, not significantly genetically altruistic — that is, it must not have been weeded out by natural selection. We can see that people do, in fact, often appear to behave altruistically; and since there are multiple ways in which evolutionary processes plus culture could produce individuals whose top-level goals include the good of others, there is no need to look for strained explanations of this behaviour in egoistic terms. Guest lecturer, Winterschool for molecular genetic approaches in zoology and conservation genetics. Connecticut Valley Zebrafish Meeting. Once culture comes into play, there are even more possibilities: More response to the love. Understanding how an adaptive allele contributes to phenotypes and overall fitness.
The accusations came hot and heavy. The genomic basis of parallel evolution in three-spined sticklebacks Advisor: Graduate Students Advisory Board, Dept. We can see that people do, in fact, often appear to behave altruistically; and since there are multiple ways in which evolutionary processes plus culture could produce individuals whose top-level goals include the good of others, there is no need to look for strained explanations of this behaviour in egoistic terms. We have a built in self care mechanism. In order for behavioural altruism or the capability of acquiring altruistic behaviours culturally to survive in a population in the long term it must be, at the least, not significantly genetically altruistic — that is, it must not have been weeded out by natural selection. PZ says that the fact that Ogvorbis confessed and repented absolves him of fault.
Butyeah, nice double standard PZ. Given that decision making has been shown to start in the ccurriculum centers of the brain, I would say that there is a good chance that you are correct, P.
And yet, it is nearly universally regarded as a Good; those who are especially enamored of Charity often strenuously oppose Welfare or Reform; and often, it is those who citae already poor who are currriculum generous with their giving. Those are disparate acts. Philosophy is for having a set of mental curriculym to use, not as an end.
Ogvorbis deserves ONLY support and empathy, in spite of how many little girls he admits he raped. Suppose an individual who knows they are sterile murders all their near relatives in order to inherit their wealth. Charity is famously useless for actually solving a social ill, such as poverty; it can alleviate the suffering, temporarily, of those it touches, but does nothing for structural problem that created their conditions in the first place.
It’s too damn early for philosophy
Victims in FTB-speak are only fodder to the cause, believed and supported only when curricuum aids their narrative. Society for Molecular Biology and Evolution Meeting. Of course most people will probably disagree with me. Baltischer RundschauApril, European Society for Evolutionary Biology Congress. Kinship has a dark side as does reciprocity.
More proof that PZ and his friends adhere to only one moral rule: Given the invisibility ring what would most people do versus overt virtue signaling on the blog? Society for Genetics, Wittenberg, Germany. But, of course, if anyone from FTB sees it, they will grasp any random hollow straw from here to the Oort cloud trying to refute. Population genomics curriculuum parallel phenotypic evolution in stream-lake stickleback. Ogvorbis is not the problem, the FTB reaction to Ogvorbis, and their massive dose of self-righteous hypocrisy is.
The genomic basis of adaptive evolution in threespine sticklebacks. I reckon probably not.
And, even then, there are problematic cases, such as that where giving that food to another will cause one to starve themselves. Pharyngula ScienceBlogsOctober, More response to the love. It seems to me that moral philosophy is less true than useful.
Email required Address never made public. The rest of what you say seems to support an instrumental form of altruism signaling and reputation and not intrinsic altruism for its own sake — hemidactylus It is a way of showing that your are prosperous enough — morally upright enough — to have excesses resources to give.
Sure we understand concern for family members and would tend to condemn apathy toward loved ones, but some of the worst social ills arise from preferential treatment toward family members. They are dragging the atheist community through the sewers yet again by demonstrating their complete lack of humanity and compassion for rape victims. But the practical reality is that if humans did anything other than practice moral philosophy, society would implode very quickly and take most human life with it.
It’s too damn early for philosophy
Teaching Assistant, Wesleyan University. Thank you for letting their words shine.
I think of Rick Rescorla making the ultimate sacrifice getting his people out of the World Trade Center on Cooperative systems with rough equality of position provide better thriving environments than antagonistic or unequal ones.
International Society for Developmental Biology Congress.